written at 2:13 p.m. on 2002-11-19

poeticdiary

Layout - 18%

I like this. It relates to the content of the diary quite well, subdued and wistful. The colours and text were easy to look at. And it appears to have been self designed. Bonus.

Content - 45%

I groaned when I opened your page. I am not a poetry fan. Reading your page managed to change my mind. From the poetry itself, which is of an excellent standard that even I enjoyed reading, to the informative faq, which I found helpful, this page is fantastic and a credit to you.

Navigation - 5%

No problems here. Everything is organised and in one place.

Errors - 10%

I can't really comment on grammatical errors, even if you had some they would be part of the poetry! Spelling was fine, all your links worked.

Contact - 5%

Email, book, map, notes, comments.

Commitment - 5%

I wouldn't be too harsh with you on this subject as you can only write as inspiration takes you, but as it turns out I didn't need to be. Geez, how much can you write in one day?

Extras - 5%

You introduced me to the world of trading cards. Thank you! Your review site is a great idea, so I have applied! On top of this you have quizzes, rings. awards and more. You can't get bored here.

Total - 93%

Comments - 'Wow' is pretty much the only word that comes to mind. And 'Well Done!'


Prev | Next | Design | comment | links | Dland